Current:Home > ScamsFact-checking 'Twisters': Can tornadoes really be stopped with science? -Secure Growth Solutions
Fact-checking 'Twisters': Can tornadoes really be stopped with science?
View
Date:2025-04-26 06:42:13
Spoiler alert! We're discussing important plot points and the ending of this summer's tornado-chasing thriller "Twisters" (in theaters now), so blow on down the road if you haven't seen it yet.
"Twisters" has twin interwoven storylines driving the mayhem forward.
One is the tension-filled chemistry between the disaster movie's protagonists, dueling storm chasers Kate Carter (Daisy Edgar-Jones) and Tyler Owens (Glen Powell). The actors bring a totally believable zip to the brewing relationship.
The other is Kate's lifelong obsession with figuring out how to use science to make a raging tornado literally vanish literally into thin air. And on that count, we have largely ventured into the realm of the improbable.
Join our Watch Party!Sign up to receive USA TODAY's movie and TV recommendations right in your inbox
Need a break? Play the USA TODAY Daily Crossword Puzzle.
Kevin Kelleher was a tornado consultant both on director Lee Isaac Chung's Oklahoma-rooted tale as well as Jan de Bont's 1996 original "Twister." Kelleher spent most of his career at the National Severe Storms Laboratory in Norman, Oklahoma.
The first film focused on deploying tiny flying balls into a tornado to better understand the DNA of that windy phenomenon. "It was accurate except for the fact that we didn't have tiny computers that could fit in small balls 30 years ago," he says.
Can you make a tornado vanish like in 'Twisters'? Only theoretically, expert says
Kelleher says that while it's now conceivable to replicate the tech in "Twister," that's not the case for "Twisters."
In the updated version, Kate's brainstorm involves chasing a massive tornado and performing a timed release of a few dozen big canisters of chemicals into the updraft, which reacts with the moisture in the funnel and eventually causes it to weaken and disappear.
Such tech would obviously be a boon to those communities that suffer damage and loss of life every year at the hand of tornados, largely Midwestern and Southern states. The science is technically sound.
"There are chemicals that can absorb water, and as we know, moisture and rain is a fuel for thunderstorms," Kelleher says. "Theoretically, if you remove moisture, you diminish the effects of a tornado."
That is indeed what we see in "Twisters" as Daisy single-handedly defuses a massive tornado as it's about to level a nearby town. She does so by driving a pickup into the path of the storm and dramatically popping the tops off her chemicals, watching as they get sucked into the vortex and, ultimately, neutralize the threat.
Unfortunately, Kelleher says, what we see in "Twisters" is not possible − for now.
"It's a matter of scale, really," he says, adding tornado experts agree that “to have any sort of effect remotely like this, you'd likely need 22,000 tons of this stuff, which you obviously couldn't just back onto a pickup truck's trailer and drive into a storm. So it's pretty science fiction at this point."
Radar panels that detect a tornado's shape exist, but are they as portable as 'Twisters' shows?
There's another high-tech component to "Twisters" that's worthy of inquiry. It involves a second group of storm chasers led by Javi (Anthony Ramos) who are trying to get more data by quickly surrounding the moving funnels with three door-sized radar panels that use triangulated data to conjure a computer-generated image of the tornado's structure.
In the movie, Javi and his team jump out of their trucks and within seconds pop their radar shields into place. Does such equipment exist? Yes and no. Again, it's about scale.
"For the movie, they basically miniaturized the radar (shields)," Kelleher says. "There really are devices that can (take images of tornado shapes), but to hop in and out of vans like that with them, no way. And they forgot that each one needs its own generator."
Kelleher says tornado science is an ever-evolving pursuit of data on a quirk of nature that repeatedly defies full understanding. The minute you think a tornado is about to form and touch down, it will vanish. And vice versa, as blue skies seem to morph into a menacing horizon in mere moments.
But given the lives and property damage at stake, the research into understanding this elusive phenomenon will continue, no matter how daunting the task, he says. Even small jumps in knowledge can lead to earlier warnings that might cut death tolls.
In the end, "Mother Nature is powerful, and we are not. Our ability to influence and change the weather is minimal."
veryGood! (5334)
Related
- Former longtime South Carolina congressman John Spratt dies at 82
- Exodus From Canada’s Oil Sands Continues as Energy Giants Shed Assets
- What SNAP recipients can expect as benefits shrink in March
- Daniel Ellsberg, Pentagon Papers leaker, dies at age 92 of pancreatic cancer, family says
- Google unveils a quantum chip. Could it help unlock the universe's deepest secrets?
- North Carolina’s Goal of Slashing Greenhouse Gases Faces Political Reality Test
- 3 children among 6 found dead in shooting at Tennessee house; suspect believed to be among the dead
- Losing Arctic Ice and Permafrost Will Cost Trillions as Earth Warms, Study Says
- Which apps offer encrypted messaging? How to switch and what to know after feds’ warning
- Despite Pledges, Birmingham Lags on Efficiency, Renewables, Sustainability
Ranking
- A South Texas lawmaker’s 15
- To safeguard healthy twin in utero, she had to 'escape' Texas for abortion procedure
- Arizona to halt some new home construction due to water supply issues
- Why Miley Cyrus Wouldn't Want to Erase Her and Liam Hemsworth's Relationship Despite Divorce
- 'Survivor' 47 finale, part one recap: 2 players were sent home. Who's left in the game?
- Stone flakes made by modern monkeys trigger big questions about early humans
- Nusrat Chowdhury confirmed as first Muslim female federal judge in U.S. history
- House Rep. Joaquin Castro underwent surgery to remove gastrointestinal tumors
Recommendation
Which apps offer encrypted messaging? How to switch and what to know after feds’ warning
Wray publicly comments on the FBI's position on COVID's origins, adding political fire
Carbon Footprint of Canada’s Oil Sands Is Larger Than Thought
Montana man sentenced to 18 years for shooting intended to clean town of LGBTQ+ residents
IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
Why Chrishell Stause and G Flip's Wedding Won't Be on Selling Sunset
Ja Morant suspended for 25 games without pay, NBA announces
Lawmakers again target military contractors' price gouging